Others Educational Info

Considering an IUD? Understanding the Risks and Safer Alternatives


When considering a dependable, long-term contraceptive method, the IUD stands out as one of the most efficacious options. Nevertheless, as with any medical intervention, there exist potential risks that patients should familiarize themselves with before reaching a decision.
Were you aware that certain women may undergo unforeseen bleeding, intense pain, or mood fluctuations following the insertion of an IUD? More severe complications, such as pelvic inflammatory disease, infertility, or issues during subsequent pregnancies, are also possible for some individuals.

When making decisions regarding your health, it is imperative that you have a thorough awareness of all relevant information. We shall discuss the possible risks associated with IUDs in this article. Additionally, we'll explore alternative options that could meet your needs without posing similar risks to your well-being.

Exploring the Fundamentals of IUD

Intrauterine devices (IUDs) stand as a prevalent choice for birth control, embraced by approximately 10% of fertile-age women in the United States. With a staggering effectiveness rate of over 99%, these devices ensure that fewer than 1 in 100 women utilizing an IUD will experience pregnancy annually. Renowned for their sustained efficacy, IUDs offer a long-lasting solution. Once inserted, these devices can remain in place for several years.

It is an appealing option for women seeking a birth control method that doesn’t demand daily attention. While other contraceptives, like the pill, primarily prevent pregnancy by halting ovulation, IUDs operate differently, and their mechanisms vary between hormonal and copper variations. There are two types of IUDs you need to know about.

Hormonal IUDs dispense progestin, a synthetic version of progesterone, thickening cervical mucus to impede sperm from reaching an egg.
On the other hand, copper IUDs, devoid of hormonal components, employ a small amount of copper to stimulate an immune response in the uterus, establishing a hostile environment for sperm.

What Are the Potential Side Effects of Intrauterine Devices (IUDs)?

IUDs can cause bothersome side effects for some users. Both hormonal and copper IUDs are associated with side effects. Understanding potential side effects helps users decide if an IUD is right for them.

Hormonal IUD Side Effects

Hormonal IUDs such as Mirena, Kyleena, Liletta, and Skyla release progestin, which can cause side effects for some users. However, the most common side effects actually help alleviate troublesome period symptoms.

Many find their periods become lighter and less painful with an IUD. Some may stop getting their period altogether, which is considered normal. This makes hormonal IUDs an appealing option for heavy bleeding, endometriosis, or those wanting to avoid monthly periods. Potential side effects can include temporary discomfort during
insertion and a few days of cramping or back pain afterward.
There is also a possibility of irregular spotting between periods or changes inregularity or duration.
While insertion may cause temporary pain, over time, the IUD balances hormones and improves problematic period symptoms for most. Its important to discuss any health or fertility goals with a doctor to determine if a hormonal IUD could provide symptom relief. In general, adverse effects tend to be mild and manageable.

Copper IUD Side Effects

Some key things to expect with the copper IUD Paragard include potential changes to your menstrual cycle. As Paragard does not contain hormones, common side effects involve heavier periods, increased cramping, and irregular bleeding between periods, especially in the first few months of use.For many, though, these side effects tend to lessen over time as the body adjusts. Some also experience spotting between periods or pain upon insertion that may last a few days.
Unfortunately, some women have faced serious issues with Paragards removal. Its T-shaped design aims to flex upward during extraction but allegedly can become rigid instead. This has led to breakage inside the uterus in some cases. Broken plastic pieces left behind can migrate elsewhere in the body or become lodged in the uterine wall. Some needed surgery to remove shards, while others faced ongoing complications. Tor Hoerman Law notes that over 2,200 product liability lawsuits have been filed against Paragards manufacturers concerning such removal
The Paragard lawsuit argues the T-shape makes it prone to fracturing on removal and that its risks were not properly warned. They further claim negligence for the alleged design defect. The multi district litigation is currently consolidated in federal court to evaluate these shared concerns over Paragard.

What Are the Alternatives to IUD?

If youre seeking alternatives to intrauterine devices for contraception, consider the following options:


A woman inserts the diaphragm, a silicone cup shaped like a saucer, into her vagina before sexual activity to prevent sperm from accessing the uterus. A doctor must fit each woman for her diaphragm. It has a 6% failure rate with perfect use over a year when used with spermicide. With typical use, where it may not always be used correctly, the risk doubles to 12%.
The benefits are its reusable nature for up to a year and its ability to be inserted close to sex. Drawbacks include potential urinary tract or vaginal infections, needing to leave it in for 8 hours after sex, and it provides no STD protection. Proper fitting and use are important for effective contraception.

Cervical Cap

Like a hat, the cervical cap covers the cervix. A doctor must fit each woman for hers. When used with spermicide, it has a 20% failure rate with typical use. It can remain in place up to 48 hours after sex, allowing more flexibility than other barriers. A benefit is you can attempt conception at any time by stopping its use.
However, it provides no STD protection and infrequent prescriptions may make fittings difficult initially. It also poses bladder infection risks. Due to its mechanism, it is not recommended for women having sex multiple times per week or with pelvic disease history. Proper fitting and use impact contraceptive effectiveness.


The contraceptive sponge is a soft foam disk with an embedded spermicide. Unlike diaphragms or caps, no fitting is required and it can be purchased over the counter.
With perfect use, it prevents pregnancy in 91% of nulliparous women but this drops to 76% with typical use. As with other barriers, it allows for multiple acts of intercourse within 24 hours of insertion but provides no protection against STDs.
Benefits include convenience without a prescription and the ability to immediately attempt conception upon discontinuation. However, effectiveness depends heavily on user accuracy and consistent spermicide exposure. Sponge use also carries higher failure risks for women who have given birth previously.


Spermicide is an over-the-counter medication that is injected into the vagina to either kill or immobilize sperm. It comes in several forms such as gels, foams, and suppositories. When used alone, spermicide has been shown to fail at preventing pregnancy approximately 28% of the time.
However, when used together with other contraceptives like condoms or diaphragms, it can boost their effectiveness at preventing pregnancy.
While spermicide is affordable and easily accessible, some people report allergic reactions or sensitivity to the main ingredient nonoxynol-9. Additionally, spermicide does not protect against sexually transmitted infections and may potentially increase the risk of infection if it irritates the vaginal walls.

Vaginal Contraceptive Gels

Vaginal contraceptive gels are used as a form of birth control. The gel is applied inside the vagina using an applicator before engaging in sexual intercourse. It works by maintaining the natural pH level of the vagina, which prevents sperm from ascending into the reproductive tract and fertilizing an egg. Clinical studies have found vaginal gels to be 86% effective when used correctly. For added protection, some choose to also use condoms, diaphragms, or other
contraceptives along with the gel. Potential downsides include needing to reapply the gel within an hour of intercourse and before each separate sexual encounter.
Some individuals may experience allergic reactions, irritation, or infections from the use of the gel. It offers no defense against diseases spread by intercourse.

In summary, consideration of alternative methods to IUDs comes down to balancing effectiveness and minimizing health risks based on an individuals needs and circumstances.
A variety of barrier methods and spermicides exist that may offer more flexibility and suitability for some. Open communication with a medical provider can help weigh options to select the best fit.